With 350 trillion in debt worldwide, public and private, in 2022, a level never reached in human history, the rhetoric of guilt, which has surrounded the troubled debtor since time immemorial, is beginning to reach its limits.
“To be held”, “to be obliged”, “subjection of the debtor”, contemporary legal semantics further illustrates the moral constraint that creditors, first and foremost the banking system, seeks to exert on debtors.
However, the banking system has been both the main actor and the main beneficiary of the spectacular financialization of the economy over the past fifty years. In reality, it pursues its own interests to the detriment of the real economy, with regard to which it often behaves like a predator.
Our philosophy is to begin by taking our debt restructuring and asset protection clients out of any notion of individual culpability and providing them with expertise in identifying their creditors’ vulnerabilities, as well as protecting their assets.
Remaining combative and proactive – in a matter that tends to encourage repentance and withdrawal – seems essential to us.
Each case is unique and it would be vain and pointless to claim to list here, in abstracto, all the possible combinations.
As in all subjects, there are limits. But these limits are not those that we naturally think of.
While the contract is the product of an agreement of wills, the tort is an intentional wrongful act to which the law attaches an obligation to repair.
Civil offenses and criminal offenses are not to be confused: in order for wrongful behavior to be the subject of criminal sanctions, it is still necessary to provide for a specific incrimination (such as theft, drug trafficking, etc.), in accordance to the centuries-old principle of the legality of offenses and penalties.
The vast majority of obligations arising from the current legal world are of a contractual nature, and not tortious, and in particular those concerning relations with banks.
In many countries, the insolvency organization does not fall within the sphere of criminal law when the source of the debtor’s obligation is contractual in nature.
This is the case, for example, in France, article L.314-7 of the Penal Code only applies in tort, quasi-tort, and maintenance matters, and even then under certain conditions.
As a result, contrary to what banking establishments often strive to make believe, banking disputes most often fall within the purely civil arena (as opposed to the criminal arena).
The logic of the legislators is based on an observation of common sense: the banks and the companies which contract with the debtor have at their disposal a whole set of guarantees which they can use, and the public authorities are not intended to assist them in the recovery of their debts.
To our knowledge, no serious economic study has been conducted on the opportunity cost of debt collection and the impact of this cost on the behavior of banks.
Legal advisers who content themselves with delivering a strictly legal analysis – and unfortunately they are legion – are likely to seriously mislead their clients.
What is a theoretical analysis of the merits of a legal action worth if, in practice, it will take ten years, will cost a significant amount compared to the amount of the debt sought and can never be effectively executed? This theoretical analysis will be worth little or nothing, and will mislead those who seek advice.
A legal analysis only makes sense if it is coupled with an economic analysis of the clients’ stakes.
Experience shows that, in civil matters (as opposed to criminal matters), the levers available to debtors vis-à-vis their creditors are only limited by the imagination of the person who accompanies and advises them.
The rule of law has become both extraordinarily complex and constrained at the borders of the jurisdiction from which it emanates, financial globalization has become a reality that transcends any jurisdiction.
The combination of these two phenomena offers well-advised debtors a multitude of levers to protect their assets while allowing them to remain on strictly civilian ground.
We invite you to contact us today to determine your needs and the solutions we can provide.